Writing in a world where AI exists
Earlier today, someone sent me a screenshot. It was my essay about Bard the Bowman from Tolkien’s “The Hobbit,” fed through an AI detector, with a score blazing across the top: “100% AI-generated.” The essay opened with an anecdote about watching the movie with my best friend, explored Tolkien’s WWI trauma and how it shaped the character, and ended with the line “Sometimes you kill the dragon. Sometimes the town burns anyway.”
That's a logical fallacy: Appeal to Authority. In this case, imaginary, hallucinating authority, but still it's a case where someone doesn't address the content but simply dismisses it by pointing to someone or something official. Oh wait, there's a more specific version: Appeal to False Authority.
Everyone wrongly accused of using AI should respond with a "Logical Fallacy: Appeal to False Authority" and link to your favorite reliable source for logic references. If nothing else, it will help raise awareness of this very common logical fallacy, which would be very useful in today's baloney-filled society.
Also in venues you control, don't hesitate to disemvowel, strikethrough, or delete garbage comments. There's no need to leave verbal dog shit on the floor for other people to step in and track around.
( Read more... )
Earlier today, someone sent me a screenshot. It was my essay about Bard the Bowman from Tolkien’s “The Hobbit,” fed through an AI detector, with a score blazing across the top: “100% AI-generated.” The essay opened with an anecdote about watching the movie with my best friend, explored Tolkien’s WWI trauma and how it shaped the character, and ended with the line “Sometimes you kill the dragon. Sometimes the town burns anyway.”
That's a logical fallacy: Appeal to Authority. In this case, imaginary, hallucinating authority, but still it's a case where someone doesn't address the content but simply dismisses it by pointing to someone or something official. Oh wait, there's a more specific version: Appeal to False Authority.
Everyone wrongly accused of using AI should respond with a "Logical Fallacy: Appeal to False Authority" and link to your favorite reliable source for logic references. If nothing else, it will help raise awareness of this very common logical fallacy, which would be very useful in today's baloney-filled society.
Also in venues you control, don't hesitate to disemvowel, strikethrough, or delete garbage comments. There's no need to leave verbal dog shit on the floor for other people to step in and track around.
( Read more... )
